Japbyeong — Miscellaneous Diseases · 下
下多亡陰 Too Much Purging Loses the Yin
In plain words
This section gives the reason behind its title: too much purging loses the yin (陰). Yin and yang (陽) are the paired qi that old medicine held to make up the body, and yin is the cold, still side of the pair. First the Deukhyo (得效) says briefly that great purging damages the blood (血).
Dongwon (東垣) holds that purging is fundamentally a means of aiding yin. If yin has received a yang evil (陽邪), harmful qi of a yang nature, and heat has bound with form, what has already broken down and spoiled must be removed so that new yin can come. But if purging is done again once the yang evil is already gone, he says, the yin is lost instead.
Dongwon then brings in the words of the classic (經), doubled yin must turn to yang (重陰必陽), and says that the yin qi therefore perishes of itself; this, he says, is what is meant by too much purging losing the yin (下多亡陰). Why doubled yin turns to yang is not explained further.
The section on too much sweating losing the yang, in the part on sweating just before, carries words of Dongwon written in the same form about sweat and yang.
This section is an old theory that explained the excess of purging by the principle of yin and yang. It is not an explanation used in medicine today.
In the words of the Deukhyo (得效) and Dongwon (東垣), this section explains why too much purging loses the yin. The Deukhyo says that great purging damages blood. Dongwon says that purging is fundamentally a means of aiding yin, used when a yang evil (陽邪) has bound heat with form to remove what has broken down and bring about new yin, but that purging again after the yang evil is gone loses the yin instead, and he explains this with the saying of the classic (經) that doubled yin must turn to yang (重陰必陽).
Original, read line by line 東醫寶鑑 · Japbyeong — Miscellaneous Diseases vol. 1
-
大下傷血. 《得效》
Great purging damages blood. 《Deukhyo (得效)》
-
下者, 本所以助陰也.
Purging is fundamentally a means of aiding yin.
-
若陰受陽邪, 熱結有形, 須當除去已敗壞者, 以致新陰.
If yin has received a yang evil (陽邪) and heat has bound with form, what has already broken down and spoiled must be removed so as to bring about new yin.
-
若陽邪旣去, 而復下之, 反亡陰也.
If, once the yang evil is gone, purging is done again, the yin is lost instead.
-
經曰, 重陰必陽. 故陰氣自亡. 下多亡陰, 此之謂也. 《東垣》
The classic (經) says: doubled yin must turn to yang (重陰必陽). Thus the yin qi perishes of itself. This is what is meant by too much purging losing the yin (下多亡陰). 《Dongwon (東垣)》
下 — more passages
This is a cultural and historical record from a classical text, not a claim about any food’s effects. Nothing here is a health supplement or intended to prevent or treat disease. Consult a medical professional about health concerns. · Text: Wikisource transcription, collated with the Jangseogak copy of the 1613 wooden movable-type edition · Reading: Homiclub
