In the Northern Hemisphere, tomato seedlings set out in May bear fruit from July through October. This is the season for picking the reddest ones first from plants tied up to their stakes. Once a basketful starts coming in every other day, you have to decide how to eat them all. But there's a question that comes up even before that: what does this fruit actually do for your body?
Look up tomatoes and the first name you'll see is lycopene. It's a carotenoid, the pigment that gives the fruit its red color, and it has documented antioxidant activity. That much is established. But a compound having a certain property is one thing; eating a fruit that contains it and thereby preventing a disease is another. Keep those two ideas separate, and it becomes much clearer what you can reasonably expect from a tomato.
What Changes When You Cook Them With Oil
Human studies have confirmed one thing: your body absorbs more lycopene from tomatoes cooked with oil than from tomatoes eaten raw. That's also why sauce and paste deliver more lycopene than fresh tomatoes do.
Lycopene dissolves in fat rather than water, so the thinking is that it crosses into the body more easily when oil is present. Another explanation holds that heat softens the flesh and lets the compound escape more readily. These explanations are still conjecture, but the result itself, higher absorption, has been observed again and again across multiple trials.
Crush tomatoes into a pan with olive oil and let them simmer, or scramble them with eggs, and you've met those conditions exactly. The fat and protein in eggs aid absorption, and a long-simmered sauce with garlic and onion does the same job. Even a plate of tomatoes with mozzarella and basil brings fat into the picture once you drizzle on olive oil. Vitamin C, though, breaks down with heat, so rather than eating only cooked tomatoes, save some to eat raw. The fruit also contains potassium.
Still, "better absorption" means more lycopene enters your bloodstream. It does not mean a corresponding drop in disease. It's best not to read those two statements as if one leads to the other.
Why Results From a Capsule Don't Transfer to the Fruit
Most studies that look at blood markers used supplements made from isolated lycopene. Participants take a fixed dose in a capsule every day, and researchers measure the markers a few weeks later. Those conditions are a long way from eating food. A tomato contains vitamin C and potassium alongside its lycopene, the amount you eat changes from day to day, and whatever oil you cooked with comes along for the ride.
So the numbers from capsule trials can't simply be carried over to eating tomatoes. The next time you read an article touting the health benefits of tomatoes, check what the underlying study actually fed people. If it was a capsule, the conclusion is about the capsule.
Reports That Heavy Tomato Eaters Have Better Numbers
Observational studies have reported weak correlations between frequent tomato eating and various health markers. These studies survey what people usually eat and then compare their health later on. But a design like this can't tell you what's causing what.
People who eat tomatoes often tend to eat a wide range of vegetables and fruit, and they may walk more or sleep differently too. Correlation isn't causation, and the result may come from the diet as a whole.
So what can we say about tomatoes right now? They're a fine addition to a diet with plenty of vegetables and fruit, and cooking them with oil gets you more lycopene. There isn't enough evidence yet to claim more than that. For eating what you've picked from your own garden in season, that's plenty.
Start With Today's Harvest, Sorted by Ripeness
During the peak harvest from July through October, tomatoes come in several at a time. Set the basket on the kitchen counter and sort them like this.
- Fully ripe: Sauté with garlic and onion in olive oil, then simmer slowly into a sauce. You get fat and heat in one go.
- Just blushing red: Leave them at room temperature to ripen for a few more days. Green unripe fruit, along with the leaves and stems, contain solanine and tomatine and should not be eaten.
- For eating raw: Pair with mozzarella and basil and drizzle with a tablespoon (about 15 ml) of olive oil.
If you have acid reflux, it's safer to avoid tomatoes on an empty stomach or right before bed. Their acidity can irritate the lining of the esophagus. Some people with migraines are sensitive to foods containing tyramine, so it's worth knowing which foods don't agree with you and steering clear of them.
The biggest tomato-growing countries are China, India, Turkey, the United States, and Italy. Planting and harvest months, along with how to stake the plants, are laid out in our tomato crop guide, which you can adapt to your local climate.
Today, pick out a couple of the ripest ones, crush them, and drop them into a pan with a little olive oil. A few minutes of simmering turns them into a sauce, and you'll get more lycopene than you would from the same tomatoes eaten raw.
